71 List – 2 : Problems and RRP law-draft that would solve them

(A detailed version of this chapter in notes #301.005 on http://facebook.com/mehtarahulc )

No. Problem Which proposed DRAFTS would reduce the problem?
Poverty related poverty
1 Poverty 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. Wealth Tax

5. Inheritance Tax

6. Increasing custom duty to 300%

7. Right to Recall Reserve Bank Governor

8. Right to Recall District Education Officer

2 Lack of pensions for Elders 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Agitation for TCP

4. PM, CMs signing TCP

5. MRCM

3 Lack of supply of clean drinking water 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Equal Allowance System over Waters

4 Poor/high-cost primary education 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR State Education Minister

4. RTR District Education Officer

5 Poor/high-cost higher school education 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR State Education Minister

4. RTR District Education Officer

6 Health – high cost and poor quality colleges education 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR National Education Minister

4. RTR State Education Minister

5. RTR UGC Chairman

6. RTR University Vice Chancellor

7. Scholarship directly to students

7 AIDS Epidemic 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. Jury System

8 Poor nutrition 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

9 Poor housing 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. Wealth Tax law

5. Inheritance Law

10 Theft of God’s Property 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

11 Not considering theft of God’s Property as theft 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP
12 Population growth 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

Law and Order related problems
13 Rising thefts, extortions, open organized crimes 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. Right to Recall Police Commissioner

5. Right to Recall judges

6. Jury System

7. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

14 Lawlessness in Bihar [as above]
15 Lawlessness in UP, Orissa, etc [as above]
16 Large scale cheating [as above]
17 Terrorism 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. Wealth Tax for Military

5. Inheritance Tax for Military

6. Development of Nuclear Weapons

7. Strengthening Military

8. Execution by Majority Voting

Crimes against women, dalits etc.
18 Rising crimes against women such as molestation, rape and harassment 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. MRCM

4. RTR District Police Commissioner

5. RTR judges

6. Jury Trials

7. Truth Serum Test in rape cases

8. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

19 Rising harassment of single women [as above]
20 Domestic violence against women, children [as above]
21 Rising atrocities on dalits [as above]
Civil nuisances
22 Poor quality of goods and service 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR judges

4. Jury Trials

23 Loan sharking, as well asNot repaying the debt [above]
Problem related to Legal Infrastructure
24 Slow courts, Fewer courts than what is needed 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR judges

4. Jury System

5. Creating new 100, 000 courts

6. Abolition of interviews in recruiting judges

25 Slow Lawmaking Process 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP
Problems related to Corruption, Nexuses
26 Corruption in civil supply department (Ration Card System) 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall Civil Supplies Minister

4. Right to Recall District Supply Officer

5. Procedure to change ration shop

27 Police Atrocities 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

4. Jury System over Policemen

28 Corruption in junior (below SP) police 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP\

3. Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

4. Jury System over Policemen

29 Corruption in Revenue (Land) Department 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall Chief Minister

4. Right to Recall State Land Record Officer

5. Torrance System: compulsory registration of sales

6. Land records on net (with owner’s permission)

30 Corruption in judges of lower courts 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Jury System

4. Right to Recall Principal Sessions judges

5. Right to Recall Four Senior Sessions judges

6. Recruitment by written exams (no interviews)

31 Corruption in senior (District Police Commissioner or above) policemen 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall Chief Minister

4. Right to Recall Home Minister

5. Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

6. Right to Recall IGP

7. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

32 Corruption in junior officers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall (Various senior officers)

4. Jury System over Junior Officers

33 Corruption in officers/experts of RBI 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall RBI Governor

4. Jury System over RBI Staff

5. Citizens’ Rupee System : rupees will be manufactured only after approval of citizens

6. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

34 Corruption in officers of banks. 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall SBI Chairman

4. Merger of all PSU banks with SBI

5. Jury System over Bank Staff

35 Corruption in PSUs directors/managers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR Prime Minister

4. RTR Chief Minister

5. RTR Ministers in-charge of PSUs

6. RTR important PSU Chairman such HPCL etc

7. Jury System over PSU staff

36 Blackmailing by newspaper-owners, TV channel owners 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall RTR National Newspaper Editor

4. Right to Recall State Newspaper Editor

5. Right to Recall District Newspaper Editor

6. Right to Recall Doordarshan Chairman

7. Right to Recall State TV Channel Chairman

8. Right to Recall District TV Channel Chairman

9. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

37 Corruption in MPs, MLAs etc ; 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall MP

4. Right to Recall MLA

38 Corruption of I-Tax, Excise, Customs etc officers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR National Finance Minister

4. RTR State Finance Minister

5. RTR, Chairman Central Board of Direct Taxation

6. RTR, Chairman Central Board of Indirect Taxation

7. Jury System over Tax Dept Staff

8. Reducing Excise

9. Repealing VAT, Sales Tax, GST, Octroi

10. Giving 33% of Customs Duty collected to citizen

11. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

39 Corruption in High court judges 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR High Court Chief judge

4. RTR Four Senior High Court judges

5. Recruitment by seniority only, no interview

6. Jury System in High Court

7. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

40 Corruption in Supreme court judges 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR Supreme Court Chief judge

4. RTR Four Senior Supreme Court judges

5. Recruitment by seniority only, no interview

6. Jury System in Supreme Court

7. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

41 Other cases of corruption/nexuses 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall various dept heads

4. Jury Sys

Problems related to Inefficiency
42 Inefficiency of policemen 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall National Home Minister

4. Right to Recall State Home Minister

5. Right to Recall CBI Director

6. Right to Recall Police Commissioner

7. National ID System

8. With approval of citizen, his criminal record will be put on internet

9. Jury System over Policemen

43 Inefficiency civil supply officers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall District Supply Officer

4. Enabling citizen to change his ration shop

44 Inefficiency of judges in lower courts 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Creating 100000 new courts

4. Jury System

5. National ID system

6. With approval of citizen, his criminal record will be put on internet

45 Inefficiency of other officers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Jury System

46 Inefficiency in MPs, MLAs, Ministers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall MP

4. Right to Recall MLA

5. Right to Recall Minister

47 Inefficiency of judges in High courts 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

48 Inefficiency of judges in Supreme court 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. RTR Supreme Court Chief judge

49 Inefficiency RBI Directors/officers 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall RBI Chairman

50 Inefficiencies in junior staff 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Jury System

Problems in Banking, Finance
51 Increasing money supply without citizens’ permission 1. Agitation for TCP2. PM, CMs signing TCP

3. Right to Recall Reserve Bank Chairman

4. Citizens Rupee System : RBI can manufacture rupees only after approval of citizens

5. Imprisonment, Execution by Majority Voting

52 Creating debt on nation without citizens’ permission Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Reserve Bank Chairman

53 Govt gives guarantees without citizens’ permission Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Reserve Bank Chairman

54 Issuing loans to insiders in banks Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Reserve Bank Chairman

Citizens Rupee System : RBI can manufacture rupees only after approval of citizens

55 Insider trading in stock market Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Reserve Bank Chairman

Citizens Rupee System : RBI can manufacture rupees only after approval of citizens

Problems related with Infrastructure
56 Poor Tele-communication Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Communication Minister

Right to Recall TRAI Chairman

300% Customs Duties on Import

57 Poor roads, worse footpaths Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Mayor

Right to Recall Municipal Commissioner

Jury System over City Engineering Staff

58 Poor Trafficking Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Mayor

Right to Recall Municipal Commissioner

Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

Right to Recall City Bus System Chairman

Jury System over Traffic Policemen

59 Poor Railways Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Railways Minister

Increase in Ticket Prices (5 cheap tickets per person per year)

60 High charge of TV-cable, DTH Service Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Communication Minister

61 Electricity : expensive, poor supply Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall National Electricity Minister

Right to Recall State Electricity Minister

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Electricity Minister

Ration System over Electricity

62 Poor Irrigation Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall State Irrigation Minister

Equal Allowance System over Waters

63 Bad Town Planning Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Mayor

Right to Recall Municipal Commissioner

Environment related Problems
64 Dirty Streets Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Mayor

Right to Recall Municipal Commissioner

65 Polluted air Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Chairman, Pollution Control Board

Equal Allowance System over Pollutants

66 Polluted water Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Chairman, Pollution Control Board

Equal Allowance System over Pollutants

67 Depletion of underground water Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Water Guard

Equal Allowance System over Underground Water

68 Depletion of forests and wild-life Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Water Guard

Equal Allowance System over Forest Woods

69 Pollution in oceans (oil leaks) Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Pollution Control Minister

70 Other environmental problems Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Pollution Control Minister

Problems in Taxation
71 Ambiguous tax laws Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

TCP over Tax clauses

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Chairman, Taxation Board

72 Income tax evasion Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Chairman, Taxation Board

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury Trial over Taxation Cases

73 Sales tax evasion Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Repealing Sales Tax

74 Excise evasion Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Chairman, Excise Board

Eliminating Excise for most items

Reducing Excise for other items

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury Trial over Excise Cases

75 Property tax evasion Agitation for TCPRight to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Chairman, Taxation Board

Wealth Tax Law

Torrance System for Land Records

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury Trial over Property Tax Cases

76 Octroi evasion Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Remove Octroi

77 Evasion of other taxes Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Finance Minister

Right to Recall Chairman, Taxation Board

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury System over Tax Cases

78 Not taxing the farmers Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Rs 100,000 per family member of extra exemption for farmers ; all taxation at par

Problems related to Govt Expenditure
79 Rising govt expenses Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

RTR over Ministers

RTR over Dept Heads

Disclosure of all Expenses

Jury System over Expenses

80 Non profitable PSUs Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

RTR over Ministers Heading PSUs

RTR over PSU Heads

90 Rising non-performing assets Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall RBI Governor

Citizens’ Rupee System : rupees will be manufactured only after approval of citizens

Problems related to External Trade
82 Falling Rupee Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall RBI Governor

Citizens’ Rupee System : rupees will be manufactured only after approval of citizens

83 Rising external debt Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Prohibition on GoI Debt

84 Rising gap between imports and exports Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

300% Customs Duty

Giving 33% of Customs Duty collected to citizens

MRCM – stable monthly income for labor

Compulsory savings for labor with high wages

Hire-fire labor laws

Reducing pollution laws to 1930 US levels

Universal PF scheme

Removing employer’s PF scheme

Removing Excise on most items

Problems related with Military
85 Poor defense forces Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Right to Recall Defense Minister

MRCM

Wealth Tax, Inheritance Tax

Improvement in Income Tax

300% Customs Duty

Giving 33% of Customs Duty collected to citizens

MRCM – stable monthly income for labor

Compulsory savings for labor with high wages

Hire-fire labor laws

Reducing pollution laws to 1930 US levels

Universal PF scheme

Removing employer’s PF scheme

Reducing zoning restrictions

Hiring 20,00,000 soldiers

Hiring 20,00,000 engineers etc to build weapons

Making Military Training compulsory after class-8

86 Corruption in Military Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Right to Recall Defense Minister

Jury System

87 Not enough soldiers, low salaries of soldiers Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

MRCM

Wealth Tax, Inheritance Tax

Improvement in Income Tax

Increasing salaries of soldiers

Hire 20,00,000 more soldiers

88 Poor status of arms manufacturing Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Right to Recall Defense Minister

MRCM

Wealth Tax, Inheritance Tax

Improvement in Income Tax

300% Customs Duty

Giving 33% of Customs Duty collected to citizens

MRCM – stable monthly income for labor

Compulsory savings for labor with high wages

Hire-fire labor laws

Reducing pollution laws to 1930 US levels

Universal PF scheme

Removing employer’s PF scheme

Reducing zoning restrictions

Hiring 20,00,000 engineers etc to build weapons

Making Military Training compulsory after class-8

Ethnic Problems
89 Reducing caste-based reservations Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Economic Choice over Reservation

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury System over Cattiest remarks, atrocities

90 Tension due to casteism Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

MRCM

Economic Choice over Reservation

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Jury System over Cattiest remarks, atrocities

91 Atrocities on dalits Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

MRCM

Right to Recall Supreme Court judges

Right to Recall High Court judges

Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

Right to Recall Dalit Atrocities Prevention Commission Chairman

Jury System over Cattiest remarks, atrocities

92 Ram Janambhoomi Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Law to handover plot to National Hindu Trust

93 Hindu Muslim tension Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Right to Recall CM

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Right to Recall District Police Commissioner

Right to Recall Dalit Atrocities Prevention Commission Chairman

Jury System over Cattiest remarks, atrocities

94 Secessionist movement in Kashmir Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Make JK MLAs pass resolution to abolish Art-370

Merge JK with HP, Uttaranchal

95 Secessionist movement in Asam Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

MRCM

Right to Recall PM

National-ID system

Building Relatives’ (Kith, Kin) Registry

System to identify, expel Bangladeshies

96 Secessionist movements in Manipur, Nagaland, Tripura, Meghalaya Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

MRCM

Right to Recall PM

National-ID system

Building Relatives’ (Kith, Kin) Registry

System to identify, expel Bangladeshies

97 Non-Hindu Infiltrators from Bangladesh Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

National-ID system

Building Relatives’ (Kith, Kin) Registry

System to identify, expel Bangladeshies

98 Atrocities on Hindus in Bangladesh, Pakistan, Fiji etc. Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Law to enable Hindus in Bangladesh, Pakistan etc to enter India for next 10 years

Civil Problems
99 Slow and tedious divorce proceedings Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Jury Trial over Family Dispute

Prompt Divorce for Woman

Abolish DVA

Abolish 498A

100 Slow proceedings of cases related to rent, lease etc Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Law for Registration of all Rental Agreements with specification of parameters

Jury Trial over Rental Disputes

101 Improve debt recollection WITHOUT creating inhuman situations Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall PM

Right to Recall Chief Minister

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Registration of ALL loans

Jury Trial over Loans

Jury Trial over Loan Sharking

102 Worsening nature of charities, religious/non-religious trusts Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Right to Recall Charity Commissioner

Jury Trial over Charities

103 Worsening administration of co-operative societies Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Right to Recall, Registrar Co-op Societies

Right to Recall Police Commissioner

Right to Recall Co-Op Chairman inside co-op

Jury Trial over Charities

104 Worsening of Labor Unions, Unions of Government Employees etc Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Right to Recall Labor Minister

Right to Recall Labor Commissioner

Right to Recall Labor Court judges

MRCM – to create stable income for labor

Compulsory savings for Labor with high salary

Hire-Fire laws

Jury Trial over Labor Disputes

105 Worsening of administration Company Affairs Agitation for TCPPM, CMs signing TCP

Right to Recall Supreme Court Chief judge

Right to Recall High Court Chief judge

Right to Recall Minister, Company Affairs

Right to Recall Registrar of Companies